Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Fiona's avatar

“The real issue isn’t glyphosate. It’s how we farm.”

That was probably the single best round-up (heh, sorry, couldn’t resist) of “The Round-Up Problem” I’ve seen, because it’s one of the few to squarely identify that as the core problem. No the evil chemicals themselves, as such (thank you also for “chemophobia”), but the whole monoculture-focussed, “nature is there to be plundered” attitude of modern farming.

Of course, with a population of 7 billion to feed, arable farmland vanishing under the press of housing, and water access increasingly fraught, (not to mention climate change, of course - there, I said it!), food production is pretty bloody fraught to start with. There are no simple answers - not going vegan or vegetarian (a lot of useful, edible animals thrive in marginal lands that can’t produce human-edible food plants at any scale)(but eating LESS meat would definitely help), not going organic (it’s still a focus on monocultural food production, just with different inputs), not a wholesale turn to regenerative or multi-crop agricultural practices (although it doesn’t harm), not even trying to focus on native food production to stop forcing farmland to grow what doesn’t naturally thrive there (although again, that won’t harm).

So we need these discussions to say “if we can’t use herbicides, how do we feed everyone?”.

(I have heard it said that there is, in fact, enough food for everyone, but it’s incredibly unevenly distributed because of the savage wealth imbalances on the planet, plus food wastage. I’d be interested to follow that one up).

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts